How to Choose Between Zapier, n8n, and Make
The Short Answer
Zapier if you want the easiest setup and have budget. You'll get there fastest, with minimal friction.
n8n if you're technical or want to self-host. I use n8n daily for production workflows. It's powerful, fair-code, and costs nothing if you run it yourself.
Make if you want visual workflow building at a lower price than Zapier. It's an excellent middle ground if budget matters more than simplicity.
The choice depends on your technical comfort, budget, and how much control you need. Read on to find your answer in 5 minutes.
Zapier: The Easy Button
Zapier is the household name for automation. If a non-technical founder has automated anything, it's probably Zapier.
Pros
- Easiest to learn. The visual builder is intuitive. You can build your first Zap in minutes.
- 7000+ integrations. Zapier integrates with almost everything: Stripe, HubSpot, Shopify, Slack, Google Sheets, Airtable, you name it. Chances are your tools are already there.
- Excellent for non-technical teams. Your entire team can build automations without code.
- Strong community. Documentation, templates, and community forums are everywhere.
- Multi-user support. Easy to add team members and assign automations.
Cons
- Expensive at scale. Pricing is per-task. 10 automations might cost £50/month. 100 automations can hit £500+ per month. Costs accelerate quickly.
- Limited logic. Complex conditional logic requires workarounds. Nested conditions get expensive fast.
- Locked into their pricing. You're entirely dependent on Zapier's price changes. They've raised prices before.
- Execution time delays. Tasks aren't instant. Triggers can take minutes to fire.
n8n: The Powerhouse
n8n is the technically advanced option. It's what I reach for when I need serious logic or cost control.
Pros
- Self-hosted option = free. Deploy n8n on your own server (AWS, DigitalOcean, etc). Pay only for hosting, not per-task. Unlimited workflows.
- Powerful logic nodes. Code nodes, conditional logic, loops, functions—you have access to real programming power.
- AI agent nodes. Build AI-powered automations with GPT, Claude, or other LLMs. Built-in support.
- Fair-code licence. Source code is available. You can audit it, fork it, contribute. You're not in a black box.
- Webhooks and APIs. Receive data from anywhere. Send data anywhere. Full control.
- Massive cost saving at scale. 1000 workflows for £30/month vs Zapier's £5000+.
Cons
- Steeper learning curve. You need basic technical understanding. The interface is more complex than Zapier.
- Fewer pre-built integrations. You often build integrations yourself using HTTP nodes or webhooks. More flexibility, more work.
- Infrastructure if self-hosting. You're responsible for uptime, backups, updates. Not a problem if you know what you're doing. A burden if you don't.
- Smaller community than Zapier. Documentation is solid but fewer third-party templates.
Make: The Visual Builder Alternative
Make (formerly Integromat) is the middle path. Great visual builder, lower cost than Zapier, more user-friendly than n8n.
Pros
- Excellent visual workflow builder. The drag-and-drop interface is intuitive and powerful. More visual than n8n, less restrictive than Zapier.
- Much cheaper than Zapier. Pricing is scenario-based (a "scenario" = one workflow). 500+ scenarios might cost £100/month vs £500+ on Zapier.
- Good middle ground. More powerful than Zapier for complex logic, more user-friendly than n8n.
- 1000+ integrations. Strong integration library, though smaller than Zapier's 7000.
- Webhook support. Connect tools that aren't pre-integrated.
Cons
- UI can be overwhelming. All that power in the visual builder makes the interface dense. More buttons, more options, steeper initial climb.
- Some integrations less polished. Pre-built integrations vary in quality. Some are outdated.
- Scenario pricing confusing. A "scenario" can be hard to define. You might hit limits unexpectedly and be surprised by costs.
- Smaller community than Zapier. Less content, fewer templates, fewer experts online.
Decision Framework: 5 Questions to Ask Yourself
- What's your technical comfort? Non-technical? Zapier. Intermediate coding? Make. Advanced developer? n8n. This matters more than anything else.
- How many automations do you need right now, and in 6 months? If it's under 10, cost doesn't matter—pick ease. If it's 50+, n8n's self-hosted option saves thousands.
- Do you need code/AI logic? If yes, n8n or Make. Zapier will frustrate you.
- Can you afford hosting infrastructure? If you self-host n8n, you need a server. £10/month DigitalOcean is cheap. But it requires maintenance knowledge.
- How critical is vendor lock-in? Zapier keeps you dependent on them. n8n and Make give you more control. This matters more as you scale.
Cost Comparison at Different Scales
* n8n self-hosted: includes server costs (DigitalOcean, AWS). Setup and maintenance time not included.
FAQ
Can I start with Zapier and switch to n8n later?
Yes. Many teams start with Zapier for speed, then migrate to n8n or Make when costs spike. The migration isn't trivial—you'll rebuild your workflows—but it's possible. If you think you'll scale, consider starting with Make or n8n instead and save the migration work.
Is n8n self-hosted really free?
The software is free and open-source. But you pay for hosting (server costs, £10–100/month depending on scale). You also pay in your time—maintenance, updates, backups are your responsibility. For teams with 1–2 technical people, it's worth it. For non-technical teams, Zapier or Make cloud is better.
What about other platforms like Airtable Automations or Integromat Pro?
Airtable Automations are great if you live in Airtable. They're cheap and simple but limited to Airtable workflows. For broader automation needs, Zapier, Make, or n8n are more flexible. As for "Integromat Pro"—Make rebranded from Integromat, so it's the same product with a better name.
Still Unsure Which One's Right for You?
Book a Close The Gap AI Session and we'll map your automation needs, show you real examples, and help you pick the right tool for your business.
Book Your SessionOr take the quiz to see how far behind you might be on automation.
More Guides
Explore more automation and AI articles in the 8020AI guides hub.